From century-old family recipes in Wilmington's Little Italy to rustic trattorias and neighborhood pizza joints — discover the best locally owned Italian restaurants across Delaware.
16
Restaurants
3
Counties
0
Chain Restaurants
🏙️ New Castle County
ItalianDate Night
Mrs. Robino's Restaurant
A Wilmington family tradition since 1940 — now in its fourth generation, this Little Italy landmark serves homemade pasta, classic braciole, meatballs, and fresh sauces made daily. Zagat rated, Best of Delaware winner.
ItalianDate Night
Scalessa's
Old-school South Philly–inspired Italian kitchen in Wilmington's 40 Acres neighborhood — owner Donnie Scalessa is famous for baseball-sized meatballs, chicken cutlet, homemade gnocchi, and sausage with escarole.
ItalianDate Night
Ristorante Attilio
Handmade Italian dishes in Wilmington's Little Italy since 1985 — beloved for fried smelts, homemade gnocchi, pasta spezzato, and classic Sunday-style Italian comfort food.
ItalianPizza & Subs
Mazzella's Italian Restaurant
Family-owned Wilmington favorite serving award-winning specialty pizzas, fresh pasta, and classic Italian dishes made daily from quality ingredients — generous portions, hometown feel.
ItalianDate NightBar & Cocktails
Piccolina Toscana
Trolley Square institution for over 30 years — everything made in-house, from brick-oven pizzas to creative pastas and a full cocktail bar. One of Wilmington's most beloved neighborhood restaurants.
ItalianDate NightBar & Cocktails
Taverna
Rustic Italian cooking inspired by the casual kitchens and watering holes of Italy — creative pastas, grilled artichokes, wood-fired dishes, and a great bar. Two locations in New Castle County.
ItalianDate Night
La Casa Pasta
Family-owned since 1978 — a Newark institution serving homemade pasta, classic Italian entrees, seafood specialties, and a beloved Bolognese that has never left the menu.
ItalianPizza & Subs
La Pizzeria Metro
Casual restaurant serving Italian food including wood-fired pizza, plus beer and cocktails in Wilmington.
🌾 Kent County
ItalianPizza & Subs
Frederica Pizza & Pasta House
Pizza spot featuring clean surroundings, Italian dishes and thin-crust pies in Frederica.
ItalianPizza & Subs
Vincenzo's Italian Restaurant & Gelato
Casual Italian restaurant offering pizza, pasta, seafood, and other classics, plus a full bar and house-made gelato in Dover.
ItalianDate NightBar & Cocktails
Benvenuto
Upscale, Tuscan-inspired spot for prime rib and salmon, as well as wine, cocktails, and local brews in Milford.
ItalianBar & Cocktails
Roma Italian Restaurant
Long-standing Dover institution opened as a pizzeria in 1973 — family-owned and expanded to classic Italian fare, house-pulled mozzarella, and banquet facilities.
ItalianPizza & Subs
Franco's Pizza & Pasta
Traditional family-owned Italian restaurant in Dover since 1994 — authentic recipes, made-to-order pizzas, generous subs, pasta dishes, tiramisu, and cannoli crafted with love and passion.
🌊 Sussex County
ItalianPizza & Subs
Dalmata Italiano
Casual pizzeria serving traditional pies, plus homemade pasta dishes and meatballs in Rehoboth Beach.
ItalianDate Night
DiFebo's
Delaware-born and family-owned since 1989 by CIA-trained chef Lisa DiFebo — homemade pasta, family-recipe meatballs, fresh-baked bread, and coastal Italian seafood. Two Sussex locations.
ItalianPizza & Subs
Touch of Italy
Locally owned trattoria and salumeria with family recipes, award-winning wood-fired pizza, housemade pasta, and a deli & bakery counter. Best of Delaware winner. Two Sussex locations.
