HomeCuisine › Pizza & Subs

Pizza & Subs
in Delaware

From wood-fired Neapolitan pies and Detroit-style deep dish to NY-style slices, cheesesteaks, and classic Italian subs — discover the best locally owned pizza shops across all three Delaware counties.

26
Restaurants
3
Counties
0
Chain Restaurants

From wood-fired Neapolitan pies in downtown Wilmington to NY-style slices steps from the Rehoboth Beach boardwalk, Delaware’s independent pizza scene is deeper than most people realize. Every shop on this list is locally owned — no franchise locations, no corporate recipes, just dough made fresh daily by people who have been perfecting their craft for years, sometimes decades. Whether you’re chasing the crispiest crust in Hockessin or the best cheesesteak in Dover, this is your guide to the pizza and sub shops that Delaware locals actually drive out of their way for.

🏙️ New Castle County
La Pizzeria Metro
Pizza & SubsItalian
La Pizzeria Metro
Casual Wilmington restaurant serving wood-fired pizza, house Italian dishes, plus beer and cocktails — a neighborhood go-to for quality pies in a relaxed setting.
Nick's Pizza Parlor & Bar
Pizza & SubsBar & Cocktails
Nick's Pizza Parlor & Bar
Locally owned retro-inspired parlor on Marsh Road — award-winning Detroit-style pies, fresh pasta, sandwiches, and a full bar with neon, checkered floors, and arcade games. Best of Delaware 2024 winner.
Stone Mill Pizza
Pizza & Subs
Stone Mill Pizza
Hidden gem in Hockessin with a wood-fired oven and rotating seasonal pies made with locally grown ingredients — creative toppings like Blue Crab with Old Bay aioli and Castelvetrano Olive. Gluten-free options available.
Cacciatori Pizza & Pasta
Pizza & Subs
Cacciatori Pizza & Pasta
Authentic New York-style pizza in Newark with hand-tossed dough, scratch-made sauce, and generous cheese — plus sub sandwiches, strombolis, and classic pasta dishes in a laid-back neighborhood setting.
DiMeo's Pizza
Pizza & SubsItalian
DiMeo's Pizza
Father-and-son owned Neapolitan pizzeria in downtown Wilmington — mozzarella di bufala flown in weekly from Campania, Naples, handcrafted super-light dough, artisan paninis, antipasti, and innovative pasta dishes. Widely considered the best pizza in Delaware.
Gianni's Pizza
Pizza & Subs
Gianni's Pizza
Family-owned by the Esposito family since 2003, this Trolley Square institution serves NY-style slices with a signature crispy crust and fresh mozzarella, plus subs, calzones, strombolis, and outdoor seating.
Naaman's Pizzeria
Pizza & Subs
Naaman's Pizzeria
Family-owned north Wilmington institution since 1989 — pizzas, cheesesteaks, and strombolis in a spacious, welcoming setting with an arcade area, ample parking, and a loyal neighborhood following built over 35+ years.
Two Cousins Pizzeria
Pizza & Subs
Two Cousins Pizzeria
Family-owned Hockessin staple since 1993 — hand-tossed pizza using locally sourced ingredients, generational homemade pasta dishes, famous garlic knots, and homemade rolls. Simple, rustic Italian done right for over 30 years.
Prima's Pizza & Pasta
Pizza & Subs
Prima's Pizza & Pasta
Locally owned by Kevin Barrow since 1992 — hand-tossed pizza with the signature Prima Spice in every box, strombolis, calzones, and pasta dishes. A proud community sponsor serving Hockessin for over 30 years.
Pizza by Elizabeths
Pizza & SubsDate Night
Pizza by Elizabeths
Independently co-owned by Elizabeth LeRoy & Elizabeth Snyder for 25+ years — upscale wood-fired pies named after famous Elizabeths, house-ground wheat crust, gourmet salads, and monthly jazz brunches in the Brandywine Valley.
🌾 Kent County
Pizzeria DiMeo
Pizza & SubsItalian
Pizzeria DiMeo
Casual family-owned Italian spot in Smyrna dishing up pizza including Sicilian-style pies, pasta, salads, and subs — a neighborhood staple with a warm, welcoming vibe.
Veronica's Pizzeria
Pizza & SubsItalian
Veronica's Pizzeria
Trendy Dover eatery specializing in brick-fired pizzas, plus spaghetti and meatballs, and classic Italian dishes — available for eat-in or takeout.
Diego's Pizza
Pizza & Subs
Diego's Pizza
Dover pizzeria serving fresh made-daily dough pizzas, wings, cheesesteaks, pasta, and classic Italian favorites — fast pickup and delivery for the whole family.
Frederica Pizza & Pasta House
Pizza & SubsItalian
Frederica Pizza & Pasta House
Beloved local pizza spot in Frederica featuring clean surroundings, thin-crust pies, and classic Italian dishes — a reliable neighborhood favorite off the beaten path.
Vincenzo's Italian Restaurant & Gelato
Pizza & SubsItalian
Vincenzo's Italian Restaurant & Gelato
Casual Dover Italian restaurant offering pizza, pasta, seafood, and classic Italian dishes with a full bar — plus house-made gelato for a sweet finish.
Two Brothers Pizza
Pizza & Subs
Two Brothers Pizza
Relaxed Dover pizzeria doling out pies with chewy crusts, subs, cheesesteaks, and stromboli — straightforward, generous portions at a fair price.
Angelo's Pizza
Pizza & Subs
Angelo's Pizza
Classic downtown Dover pizzeria dishing out pizzas, hot subs, and pastas from a humble nook with takeout and delivery options — a local go-to for no-frills Italian comfort food.
Anna & Mike's Pizza
Pizza & Subs
Anna & Mike's Pizza
Family-owned Felton gem serving New York-style pizzas and classic Italian dishes for takeout or casual sit-down dining — a local favorite with a homemade touch.
Simeron Pizza & Steak Shop
Pizza & Subs
Simeron Pizza & Steak Shop
Casual, homey Dover spot serving pizza, wings, hot and cold sandwiches, steaks, and Italian plates — a neighborhood staple that covers all the comfort food bases.
🌊 Sussex County
Milton Dough Bar
Pizza & SubsAmerican
Milton Dough Bar
Casual contemporary Milton spot specializing in New York-style pizza, burgers, sandwiches and subs, plus beer on tap — a lively neighborhood hangout in the heart of downtown Milton.
SoHo Slice Pizzeria
Pizza & Subs
SoHo Slice Pizzeria
Big city NY-slice flavor near Rehoboth Beach — hand-tossed dough, house-made sauce, and the freshest toppings, backed by over 20 years of pizza-making experience. Perfect for a grab-and-go after a day at the beach.
Henlopen Pizza Kitchen
Pizza & Subs
Henlopen Pizza Kitchen
Beloved Rehoboth Beach pizza spot with NY-style pies, cheesesteaks, and comfort fare served via counter service — a consistent local favorite for locals and beach visitors alike.
Mr. P's Pizza
Pizza & SubsBar & Cocktails
Mr. P's Pizza
Lewes institution with wood-fired pies, 19 craft beers on tap including local Delaware brews, and a cash-only policy that keeps it gloriously no-frills. Ranked #2 of 72 restaurants in Lewes on TripAdvisor — a bucket-list stop.
Nicola Pizza
Pizza & Subs
Nicola Pizza
Family-owned Delaware icon since 1971 — home of the legendary Nic-o-Boli®, invented by founder Nicholas Caggiano and still run by Nick Sr, Nick Jr, and niece Kelly. Fat-free dough and sauce, three-cheese blend, and a Delaware Restaurant Association Cornerstone Award winner.
Pomodoro Pizzeria
Pizza & Subs
Pomodoro Pizzeria
Italian family-owned Bethany Beach gem — hand-tossed NY-style pies with fresh daily dough and house-made sauce, named the #1 pizza in Delaware by multiple outlets. Small, cash-friendly, and always packed. Seasonal.
Bella Capri Restaurant & Grill
Pizza & SubsItalian
Bella Capri Restaurant & Grill
Family-owned Georgetown institution since 2001 — authentic old-school Italian with thin-crust pizza, house-made pastas, fresh mozzarella, and beloved classics like chicken parm and homemade Italian wedding soup. Everything made fresh daily.